Let's compare the advantages and disadvantages of each.
After all, both group versions exist and if we establish there stregnths and weaknesses, then we can effectively evaluate their suitability for a weekly Bible Study.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Strengths of Large Groups:
There are more potential future leaders of new groups.
There are more skills available for ministry or mission projects.
There are more experiences to draw from for sharing and learning.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Weaknesses of Large Groups:
Harder for new folks to become involved in discussion.
Less time for discussion opportunities for all attendees.
Less intimate setting, feels like a "class".
Harder for the leader to allow for participation time for each member.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Strengths of Small Groups:
Easy to allow time for participation of all group members.
Can physically fit small group format in homes, churches, schools, libraries etc
New folks will be more obvious to the "veterans" and will be ministered to
Friendship and bonding can occur easily between and among multiple members
------------------------------------------------------------------
Weaknesses of Small Groups:
New folks (and veterans) may prefer a large group as a place more easy to "hide in"
A feeling of insignificance can creep into member perspectives if the group is especially small
Facilitation of discussions is a learned art and may take some time to develop in small group leaders
-----------------------------------------------------------------
What are some other strengths and weaknesses?